Security ROI Calculator: See How Much You're Losing Right Now
Most 50-100 employee businesses lose $30,000-60,000/month in hidden productivity costs. Calculate your specific numbers and see how professional security actually makes you money.
What If Security Paid For Itself—Before It Ever Stopped an Attack?
The Reality Most Business Owners Don't See:
You're already paying for inadequate security—not just in monthly fees, but in lost productivity, wasted time, and operational inefficiencies.
- • Daytime downtime: Employees waiting for systems during updates
- • Spam overload: Time wasted deleting junk email
- • Malware incidents: Emergency cleanup calls at $500-1,000 each
- • Insurance premiums: Higher rates without documented security
What if you could eliminate these hidden costs and get institutional-grade protection?
That's not a promise—it's math. Let's calculate your specific numbers.
Answer these questions to see your hidden costs and potential savings
Include salary + benefits + overhead. Average for professional staff: $50-75/hour
Time waiting during updates, reboots, maintenance windows during business hours
Time spent deleting junk email, dealing with spam
Infections, suspicious activity, emergency IT calls
Your current cyber insurance cost
How Security Pays For Itself: The Complete Breakdown
Understanding where the ROI comes from—and why it starts immediately
The Productivity Savings (Biggest Impact)
What's Really Happening:
Your current MSP does updates, reboots, and maintenance during business hours because:
- •It's easier for them (they work 9-5)
- •They have multiple clients to serve during the day
- •Nighttime work costs them more
- •They haven't architected systems for seamless updates
What This Costs You:
Even "quick" updates add up:
- • Server reboots: 15-30 minutes
- • Workstation updates: 20-40 minutes
- • Software patches: 10-60 minutes
- • Network maintenance: 30-120 minutes
- • "Just waiting for IT" delays: Countless minutes
Conservative estimate: 3 hours per employee per week
Example: 75-person company at $50/hour loaded cost
• 75 employees × 3 hours/week = 225 hours/week
• 225 hours × 4 weeks = 900 hours/month
• 900 hours × $50/hour = $45,000/month lost
The Mainstream Difference:
We architect systems for seamless nighttime updates:
- • All updates run between 2-5 AM
- • Automated testing ensures success
- • Employees arrive to updated, working systems
- • Zero business-hour disruptions
Monthly savings: $30,000-60,000 (depending on company size)
This alone typically exceeds the security investment by 3-6×
The Spam Tax
Average office worker receives:
- • 120 emails per day
- • 15-30 are spam/junk (with basic filtering)
- • 5 minutes per day managing spam
Doesn't sound like much? Let's do the math:
• 75 employees × 5 minutes/day = 375 minutes/day
• 375 minutes × 20 workdays = 7,500 minutes/month
• 7,500 ÷ 60 = 125 hours/month
• 125 hours × $50/hour = $6,250/month wasted
The Mainstream Difference:
Cisco enterprise email gateway (same technology protecting Fortune 500):
- • Blocks 50-70% more spam than consumer/basic business filters
- • Advanced threat detection stops phishing before it reaches inboxes
- • Reduces spam management to 2 minutes/day or less
Monthly savings: $695-1,945 (depending on company size)
The Malware/Incident Tax
Typical scenario with generic MSP security:
- • Employee clicks suspicious link
- • Malware/ransomware attempt begins
- • Detection is slow or nonexistent
- • Emergency "we've been infected!" call
- • MSP charges $500-1,000+ for cleanup
- • Business loses 4-8 hours of productivity during remediation
Industry average for inadequately protected businesses:
- • 2-3 incidents per year
- • Cost per incident: $1,500-2,500 (cleanup + productivity)
- • Annual cost: $3,000-7,500
The Mainstream Difference:
Multi-layered prevention stops threats before they execute:
- • Enterprise firewall with advanced threat intelligence
- • Endpoint protection with behavioral analysis
- • Email gateway blocking malicious attachments
- • DNS filtering stopping malware downloads
- • 24/7 monitoring catching anomalies
Result: Near-zero incidents
Annual savings: $3,000-7,500
The Insurance Premium Opportunity
Cyber insurance companies assess risk based on documented security controls. Without professional documentation:
- •You're categorized as higher risk
- •Premiums reflect that risk
- •Some insurers won't cover you at all
Industry data:
- • Businesses with documented, professional security controls get 10-20% premium reductions
- • Average cyber insurance for 50-100 employee business: $8,000-15,000/year
- • Potential savings: $800-3,000/year
The Mainstream Difference:
We maintain continuous, audit-ready documentation:
- • Security control inventories
- • Compliance frameworks (NIST, CIS, etc.)
- • Vulnerability assessment reports
- • Incident response procedures
- • Backup testing records
This documentation alone often qualifies clients for lower premiums.
Annual savings: $800-3,000
Beyond ROI: The $4.5 Million Disaster You're Preventing
Operational efficiency is great. But the real value? Never facing this:
The True Cost of Ransomware (Mid-Sized Business):
Average total cost: $4.5-10 million
1. Ransom Payment: $170K-2.7M
Average demand for 50-100 employee businesses. No guarantee of data recovery even if paid.
2. Recovery Costs: $500K-2M
Emergency IT contractors at $150-300/hour, 24/7 operations for 3+ weeks, data reconstruction, system rebuilding
3. Operational Downtime: $1-3M
3-4 weeks average recovery time, lost revenue, employee salaries while unable to work, rush shipping, manual workarounds
4. Lost Clients: $500K-2M+
Contracts terminated due to breach, clients lost to competitors during downtime, long-term reputation damage
5. Legal/Regulatory: $100K-1M+
Legal fees, regulatory fines (if client data compromised), breach notification costs
6. Long-term Impact:
Insurance premium increases (30-50%), difficulty winning new business, board/investor confidence damage
The Survival Statistics:
- • 60% of small and mid-sized businesses hit with ransomware close within 6 months
- • Average recovery time: 3+ weeks (if recovery is even possible)
- • 40% of backups fail when tested during actual attacks
What You're Paying For Now vs. What You Could Have
Your current MSP might charge less, but they cost more. Far more.
| Cost/Benefit | Typical MSP | Mainstream Technology |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Service Fee | $5,000-12,000 | $9,850-19,700 (comparable or less) |
| Daytime Downtime Cost | $30,000-60,000/month | $0 (nighttime updates) |
| Spam Management Cost | $695-1,945/month | 50-70% reduced |
| Malware Incidents/Year | 2-3 ($3,000-7,500) | Near-zero |
| Insurance Premium | $8,000-15,000/year | $6,400-12,000/year (10-20% reduction) |
| Security Documentation | Created on-demand (if at all) | Continuous, audit-ready |
| Vulnerability Testing | Rarely or never | Regular assessments |
| Backup Testing | "Success" logs (untested) | Regular recovery testing |
| Ransomware Risk | "Hope it doesn't happen" | Institutional-grade prevention |
| Track Record | Unknown | 50 years, zero ransomware |
| Total Monthly Cost (Real) | $35,695-73,945/month | Net gain: $11,243-52,760/month |
Bottom Line:
Your current MSP might charge less, but they cost more. Far more.
How Other Businesses Justified the Switch
Real clients, real numbers, real ROI
Before Mainstream:
- • Generic MSP doing daytime maintenance
- • Average 4 hours/week per employee of downtime per employee
- • 2-3 per year malware incidents per year
- • 8 minutes/day per employee spam management per employee
Hidden Monthly Costs:
- Productivity loss: $32,000
- Incident cleanup: $625
- Spam time waste: $1,200
- Total: $33,825
After Mainstream:
- • All updates run at night—zero business-hour disruptions
- • Zero malware incidents
- • 60% spam reduction
- • Insurance premium reduced
ROI Calculation:
- Monthly investment: $9,850
- Monthly savings: $28,800
- Net gain: $18,950/month
- ROI: 292%
"With our previous MSP, we had ransomware that shut down our business for days. Since switching to Craig, we've had zero problems. The peace of mind alone is worth it, but the productivity gains paid for everything."
— John Lyons, President
Granite State Analytical Services
Before Mainstream:
- • Generic MSP doing daytime maintenance
- • Average 3.5 hours/week per employee of downtime per employee
- • 3-4 per year malware incidents per year
- • 6 minutes/day per employee spam management per employee
Hidden Monthly Costs:
- Productivity loss: $52,500
- Incident cleanup: $875
- Spam time waste: $1,800
- Total: $55,175
After Mainstream:
- • All updates run at night—zero business-hour disruptions
- • Zero malware incidents
- • 60% spam reduction
- • Insurance premium reduced
ROI Calculation:
- Monthly investment: $14,775
- Monthly savings: $47,200
- Net gain: $32,425/month
- ROI: 319%
"I had a need for the personal service. I had a need to be heard. He displays a genuine concern for our cyber well-being."
— Business Owner
Regional Manufacturing Company
Before Mainstream:
- • Generic MSP doing daytime maintenance
- • Average 2.5 hours/week per employee of downtime per employee
- • 1-2 per year malware incidents per year
- • 10 minutes/day per employee spam management per employee
Hidden Monthly Costs:
- Productivity loss: $37,500
- Incident cleanup: $375
- Spam time waste: $2,250
- Total: $40,125
After Mainstream:
- • All updates run at night—zero business-hour disruptions
- • Zero malware incidents
- • 60% spam reduction
- • Insurance premium reduced
ROI Calculation:
- Monthly investment: $12,312
- Monthly savings: $34,500
- Net gain: $22,188/month
- ROI: 280%
"The security documentation alone qualified us for lower insurance rates. The operational efficiencies were just a bonus."
— Managing Partner
Professional Services Firm
Three Steps to Start Making Money From Your Security
Get Your Free Assessment
We'll audit your current setup and calculate your specific ROI:
- • Document your current hidden costs
- • Identify security gaps
- • Show exact monthly savings potential
- • Provide prioritized recommendations
Timeline: 1-2 weeks • Cost: Free, no obligation
Review Your Custom ROI Report
You'll receive a detailed report showing:
- • Current productivity losses (dollar amounts)
- • Security gaps creating risk
- • Specific recommendations
- • Month-by-month ROI projection
- • Implementation timeline
Timeline: Within 2 weeks of assessment • Cost: Free
Choose Your Path
Three options:
- Option A: Fix critical gaps, stay with current MSP
- Option B: Security-only transition (hybrid model)
- Option C: Full transition (maximum ROI)
No pressure—honest recommendation based on what you actually need.
We'll show you the exact savings for your organization • No obligation • No sales pressure
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I trust these ROI calculations?
These aren't made-up numbers:
- • Productivity costs based on industry-standard $40-75/hour loaded costs
- • Time loss estimates conservative (3 hours/week—many businesses lose more)
- • Malware cleanup costs verified ($500-1,000 industry average)
- • Insurance premium reductions confirmed by multiple insurers
- • Ransomware costs from IBM, Sophos, and industry reports
We'll validate your specific numbers during the free assessment. If the ROI doesn't work, we'll tell you.
What if my employees don't lose 3 hours per week to downtime?
Even at 1 hour per week, the math still works:
- • 75 employees × 1 hour/week = 75 hours/week
- • 75 × 4 weeks = 300 hours/month
- • 300 × $50/hour = $15,000/month savings
That's still more than the security investment for most companies. And that's before spam reduction, malware prevention, and insurance savings.
Won't this ROI take time to realize?
No—the savings start immediately:
- • Day 1 of nighttime updates = Day 1 of zero business-hour downtime
- • Week 1 of Cisco email gateway = Week 1 of less spam
- • Month 1 of advanced malware prevention = Month 1 of fewer incidents
The ROI isn't theoretical—it's operational from implementation day one.
Our MSP does some nighttime updates. Do we still have this problem?
Partial nighttime updates still cause disruption:
- • Some updates require business-hour reboots
- • Emergency patches happen when convenient for MSP
- • Maintenance windows still interrupt productivity
- • Updates aren't coordinated across all systems
The question isn't "do you do some nighttime updates?" It's "do you have zero business-hour disruptions?" If not, you're losing money.
Stop Losing $30,000-60,000/Month. Start Making Money From Security.
Your calculator results show the opportunity. A free assessment shows you the reality. No obligation, no sales pressure—just honest numbers.